The United States has asked Ukraine whether it would give up the Donbas in return for joining NATO, Volodymyr Zelensky said on 13 November. “The Americans raised the question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’” Ukraine’s president told journalists, the Kyiv Independent reported on 14 November. “This was the first time this issue had been raised.”
It is an idea, not an offer, and no deal is on the table. But it sets two things against each other: a region at the centre of the fighting, and membership of NATO. Both have a price, and the numbers are large.
What is the Donbas?
The Donbas is the name for the two eastern oblasts of Donetsk and Luhansk. The war’s damage assessment counts Donetsk among Ukraine’s heavily industrialised frontline regions, and the two oblasts carry more of the war’s damage than almost anywhere else.
That shows in the damage. Of the $195.1bn of direct war damage Ukraine suffered from February 2022 to the end of 2025, $53.0bn was in Donetsk oblast and $15.5bn in Luhansk, the fifth damage and needs assessment shows. The assessment is made by Ukraine’s government with the World Bank, the European Commission and the United Nations. Together, the two oblasts hold $68.5bn, or 35% of all the damage, by our calculation. Donetsk alone accounts for 27.2%, more than any other region.
How much would it cost to rebuild the Donbas?
The same assessment puts Ukraine’s recovery and rebuilding needs at $587.7bn over 2026–35, “nearly 3 times the estimated nominal GDP” of the country in 2025, the World Bank said in February. Donetsk’s share is the largest of any oblast: $109.4bn, or 19% of the total. Luhansk adds $32.9bn.
So the Donbas accounts for $142.3bn of the rebuilding bill, about 24%, by our calculation from the assessment’s table. That cuts both ways in a negotiation: the region is costly to lose, and costly to rebuild. The assessment’s separate count of losses, the change in economic flows, including those it projects to mid-2027, puts the two oblasts at $55.8bn of Ukraine’s $666.7bn, a smaller share than their share of the damage.
What would NATO membership cost Ukraine?
Joining NATO is not free either, and we list what each NATO country spends on defence today. At their summit in The Hague in June 2025, the allies agreed to spend 5% of GDP a year on defence and security by 2035, at least 3.5% of it on core defence, the summit declaration says.
What NATO would add is the treaty’s core promise. Under Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, an armed attack against one member in Europe or North America is to be considered an attack against them all. That promise is what the idea Zelensky described would weigh against land.
What happens next?
It would take more than Washington. NATO can invite a new member only “by unanimous agreement” of its members, under Article 10 of the same treaty, so every ally would have to agree. Kyiv and Moscow would both have to accept any change on the ground.
For markets, the talks matter through the cost of the war and of what follows it. We wrote in October on how the US has pressed Kyiv to settle; the Donbas question is the latest step in that push. Earlier, it had threatened Ukraine’s weapons supply over its strikes on Russian refineries, as we reported on 13 October. For markets, the size of the rebuilding bill is the number to keep in mind: whoever holds the Donbas after a deal inherits the largest share of it.
What to watch
- Whether the White House or the State Department confirms the idea, or Moscow answers it.
- Any statement from NATO allies on membership for Ukraine.
- The next round of talks between US, Ukrainian and Russian officials.