Colombia’s economy shrank in the third quarter, and the figure lands in the middle of an argument at the central bank. Output fell 0.8% from the second quarter, once the seasons are taken out, and was only 0.5% larger than a year earlier, the statistics agency DANE said on Tuesday. It is the slowest growth of the year, in the quarter an earthquake hit the country. Three of the seven directors of the Banco de la República wanted to raise interest rates again last month, on the view that the economy was still running too hot. DANE’s figures say it was not.
The detail shows where the quarter went. Farming fell 6.7% on a year earlier, with coffee down by more than a tenth; the central bank had already blamed drier weather on the farms. Factories, finance and telecoms all shrank. Mining grew fastest, by 7.8%, and on its own it added about a third of a percentage point to growth, more than half of the total. Households and the state still spent more than a year earlier, though the state cut back from the second quarter, and imports rose while exports fell. Without the mines, the economy would barely have grown at all.
That matters because borrowing in Colombia is dear. The central bank held its rate at 12.25% last month, by four votes to three, its minutes show. Inflation is the reason. Prices rose 6.3% in the year to October, by DANE’s price index, more than twice the bank’s 3% target, and the weather pattern known as El Niño threatens food and energy bills.
The minority’s case for a rise rested on a reading of the economy that Tuesday’s figures undercut. The three directors argued that the economy “still has excess demand”, so that rates could rise now “at a lower cost” than later, when activity had slowed. They added that the earthquake’s damage to output and jobs in the third quarter “has been softened” by strong export prices and rising household incomes (our translation from the Spanish). A quarter in which output fell is hard to square with an economy that is overheating.
The board as a whole had seen the slowdown coming. Its minutes say the third quarter would carry the earthquake’s effects, the fading of the second quarter’s boost from the football World Cup and the presidential election, and the drier weather on the farms. One director in the majority had argued for a cut of half a point before joining the majority, on the grounds that the pressures on prices come from supply, from El Niño, gas shortages and fuel, and that “rate rises have little justification” against them.
Business wants the bank and the government to move. Luz Stella Murgas, who heads ANDI, the industry association, said, as Semana reported, that low investment “not only limits current economic performance” but “compromises the chances of future growth”. The bank’s own minutes call the public finances a first-order factor for the economy, and point to the economic rescue bill now before Congress.
Our view: the hawks have lost their best argument, but not the vote on inflation. With prices still rising at more than twice the target, a cut is unlikely soon. What has changed is the case for another rise, which rested on an economy too strong to need help. A quarter of falling output makes that harder to argue at the bank’s next decision, and the peso would feel any change first: one director argued that high rates have drawn in money that has pushed the currency up.