Britain’s unemployment rate fell in the three months to September, but almost every other figure in today’s jobs report points the other way: fewer people on payrolls, the fewest vacancies at small firms since 2012, the pandemic aside, and slowing pay. For a Bank of England that raised rates this month and was expected to do so again in December, that is the first hard evidence that the squeeze is working, and a reason to wait.
The headline is the good news. The unemployment rate fell to 4.6%, the Office for National Statistics said, and the share of people in work rose. But the statisticians warned in the same release that the fall “partly reflects” a change in who was being surveyed: the group of respondents leaving the Labour Force Survey had lower employment and higher unemployment than the group joining it. The survey’s answers swing from quarter to quarter, and the ONS asks users to “focus on long term movements” rather than one quarter’s change.
The tax records, which count every employee paid through the payroll system, tell a plainer story. In the early estimate for October there were 95,000 fewer payrolled employees than a year before, and the number fell between September and October too. The October figure is an early estimate and is likely to be revised, but over a full year the direction is clear.
Hiring is where the slowdown shows most clearly. Vacancies fell again in the three months to October, and the drop was concentrated at the smallest employers. Businesses with fewer than ten staff advertised 73,000 jobs, the lowest outside the pandemic since the spring of 2012. The ONS said small firms told its survey that higher labour and operating costs were holding back their hiring.
This is the labour market Clare Lombardelli, a deputy governor of the Bank of England, described a week ago. Britain is cooling “mainly through less hiring rather than more firing”, she said in a speech on 10 November. “It protects those already in work while making it much harder for those trying to get in or move on.” Redundancies are low; the people who pay are the young and the jobless, who find fewer openings.
Pay is the part of the report the Bank will read most closely, and it moved the Bank’s way. Regular pay, before bonuses, grew 3.5% on a year earlier in July to September, down from the three months before, and total pay grew at its slowest pace since 2020. In the private sector regular pay rose 3.1%. After inflation, on the ONS’s main measure, CPIH, regular pay rose just 0.2%: workers are barely keeping up.
That matters because of how Lombardelli framed the next decision. The Bank raised Bank Rate by a quarter point to 4% this month, and in the same speech she said that “in the absence of evidence of weaker inflation pressures” she saw “likely to be a case for a further increase in rates in the near term”. Her worry was that if the jobless are poorly matched to the jobs on offer, higher unemployment “may do less to ease wage pressures than it has in the past”. Today’s report is evidence that wages are cooling anyway, at least in the private sector.
Our view: the case for a December rise is weaker after this report than it was before it. Markets put the chance of a rise at the Bank’s meeting on 17 December at 82% at Monday’s close, on Central Bank Watch’s figures, before this report. A labour market that is shedding payroll jobs and slowing pay is not the kind of overheating a further rise is meant to stop, and the energy shock is already squeezing real incomes. Those who want another rise can still point to the energy shock, which Lombardelli said may yet feed into price and wage setting.
The other half of the answer comes tomorrow morning, when the ONS publishes October’s consumer price inflation. If prices are still rising faster than the Bank expected, a slowing jobs market will not save households from another rise. If inflation has peaked, today’s figures give the Monetary Policy Committee the cover it needs to hold.